Who Owns the Training Set?
The most valuable input to modern AI was assembled before anyone agreed on who owned it. The bill for that omission is now being litigated.

Editor's note, September 20, 2026: This piece was published with an outdated account of two cases: it stopped at the June 2025 fair-use ruling in Bartz v. Anthropic and omitted the $1.5 billion class settlement (announced September 2025, given final approval July 2026), and it described Getty Images v. Stability AI as having merely survived early motions when the High Court had already ruled largely against Getty in November 2025. Both passages were corrected on 20 September 2026, the status of the Reddit and music-label suits was updated, and every figure now links to its source. Further review on September 20, 2026: Qualified the fair-use discussion, removed the claim that one licensing deal establishes a market rate, and made exclusivity a conditional scenario.
Every frontier model now in commercial use was trained on a corpus that no one, including the labs that built it, can fully enumerate. Scraped web pages, pirated book archives, scanned court filings, forum posts, photographs uploaded to sites whose terms of service predate the concept of machine learning entirely — the material went in under the working assumption that assembling a dataset was a research act, not a commercial one, and that fair use would cover the gap. That assumption is now the single largest unresolved liability on the balance sheet of the AI industry, and the courts, legislatures, and licensing desks working to resolve it are, in effect, deciding who is allowed to build the next generation of these systems at all.
This is not a niche copyright dispute. It is closer to a property-rights settlement for an asset class that came into being faster than the law could describe it. And like every property dispute of consequence, the resolution will not be neutral. It will favor whoever can absorb the cost of getting it wrong.
The legal theories, and why none of them has won cleanly
The core argument advanced by the major labs is a transformative-use claim descended from cases like Authors Guild v. Google — the logic that undergirded Google Books’ scanning project a decade and a half ago. Training a model on a copyrighted work, the argument goes, does not reproduce that work; it extracts statistical patterns from it, the way a student extracts style and technique from a shelf of novels without infringing on any one of them. Courts have shown real sympathy to this framing. Judge William Alsup’s ruling of 23 June 2025 in the Bartz v. Anthropic litigation drew a line that has since become a reference point across the industry: training a model on lawfully acquired copies of books is very likely transformative and fair, but sourcing those books from shadow libraries of pirated text is a separate act of infringement that fair use does not launder. That second holding is what Anthropic ended up paying for. Rather than try the piracy claims, it agreed in September 2025 to a $1.5 billion class settlement — roughly $3,000 per work across a works list of about half a million titles — which Judge Alsup preliminarily approved on 25 September 2025 and which his successor on the case, Judge Araceli Martínez-Olguín, gave final approval on 20 July 2026, overruling all 53 objections. The distinction — legitimate acquisition versus how the material is subsequently used — has forced a re-reading of what “trained on copyrighted data” actually means as a legal exposure. It is not one question. It is at minimum two: was the copy obtained lawfully, and does the resulting use substitute for the original in the market. Two days after Alsup, Judge Vince Chhabria reached the same result on training in Kadrey v. Meta while warning that in most cases the answer would likely go the other way, because the plaintiffs before him had simply failed to prove that Meta’s models diluted the market for their books.
That second prong is where the plaintiffs’ bar has found its most durable foothold. The market-substitution argument — that a model fine-tuned to write in a particular author’s voice, or an image generator capable of reproducing a photographer’s signature style on command, competes directly with the original creator’s livelihood — addresses market harm, one part of the fact-specific fair-use analysis. It does not eliminate the need to evaluate the other factors or establish infringement merely because a generated work resembles a style. The record on it so far is mixed. Getty Images’ suit against Stability AI in the UK, which leaned on this theory, ended largely in Stability’s favour on 4 November 2025: Getty dropped its training claims mid-trial after conceding there was no evidence the training had taken place in the UK, and Mrs Justice Joanna Smith rejected the secondary-infringement claim on the ground that the model weights do not themselves store or reproduce the images, leaving only narrow trade-mark findings against early versions of Stable Diffusion. In the US, the artists’ class action against Stability, Midjourney and others, Andersen v. Stability AI, survived motions to dismiss on its core copyright claims in August 2024 and is proceeding, while the major labels’ 2024 suits against the music generators Suno and Udio have partly dissolved into licences — Universal settled with Udio in October 2025 and Warner with both in November, with Universal and Sony still litigating against Suno. Where a case does survive, that matters more than any eventual verdict: it means discovery proceeds, training logs get subpoenaed, and the actual contents of these datasets — long treated as trade secrets — start becoming exhibits.
The fight over training data no longer resembles a copyright dispute so much as a zoning dispute for an entire industry.
A third theory, quieter but potentially more consequential, concerns data scraped from platforms with explicit contractual terms — social networks, stock-photo sites, professional databases — where the claim is not copyright but breach of contract and, in some jurisdictions, unauthorized computer access. Reddit’s suit against Anthropic over scraping conducted after Reddit changed its terms of service — filed in San Francisco Superior Court in June 2025, removed to federal court by Anthropic, and sent back to the state court in March 2026 on the ground that its contract and unjust-enrichment claims are not copyright claims in disguise — is the clearest instance, and it is procedurally simpler for plaintiffs than a copyright claim: no need to prove substitution, just that a contract existed and was violated. Expect this vector to grow, because it is the one most easily generalized to any platform that hosts user-generated content and wants a cut of the value it apparently created.
A licensing market is being built in real time
While the litigation grinds forward, a parallel and faster-moving development has occurred: a licensing market for training data has materialized essentially from nothing in under three years. News organizations — the Associated Press, Axel Springer, The Atlantic, News Corp — have signed content-licensing deals with OpenAI and other labs, reportedly in the low-to-mid eight figures annually for larger publishers (the Wall Street Journal put News Corp’s multi-year deal at more than $250 million), though exact terms are rarely disclosed and the figures that circulate should be read as approximate. Stock-image libraries, music catalogs, and academic publishers have followed the same path. Reddit’s own data-licensing deal with Google, reported by Reuters at roughly $60 million a year, is one reported transaction, not an established market price for other datasets. Differences in permitted uses, duration and content limit the comparison.
What’s emerging looks less like a copyright settlement and more like a new category of commodity market, with its own intermediaries. Startups such as ProRata, which licenses content and shares half of its revenue with the publishers it draws on, and various data-licensing clearinghouses now exist purely to broker between rights holders too small to negotiate directly with a lab and labs too large to negotiate bilaterally with millions of individual creators — a role not unlike what performing-rights organizations built for music, compressed into a few years. The going assumption is that data has three separable dimensions of value: freshness (a stale training set is worth less than a live feed), structure (cleanly labeled, rights-clear data commands a premium over raw scrape), and exclusivity (non-exclusive access a rival can also license is a different product from an exclusive deal).
Who can afford to play, and who can’t
Here is the part of the story that matters most for the shape of the industry going forward: licensing markets, unlike litigation, scale in favor of whoever has the largest balance sheet. A frontier lab with tens of billions in committed capital can sign eight-figure content deals across a dozen publishers, absorb the litigation risk on the residual unlicensed corpus, and treat both costs as a rounding error against total training spend. A well-funded but non-hyperscale lab faces a much harder calculus — it can license selectively, but every dollar spent on data rights is a dollar not spent on compute, and it cannot self-insure against a plaintiff’s judgment the way an Alphabet or Microsoft-backed entity can.
The practical effect, if the current trajectory holds, is a data-rights moat stacking on top of the compute moat that already separates frontier labs from everyone else — and, as we argued in The Model Is Not the Moat, moats of this kind are where defensibility in AI has migrated. It will become progressively harder for a new entrant to assemble a training corpus that is both legally clean and competitively adequate, because the highest-quality clean sources — major news archives, large licensed image libraries, structured professional content — could become harder to access if exclusive contracts expand. The cited announcements do not establish that all or most of these sources are exclusive. Open-source and academic model-building efforts, which rely disproportionately on freely available or public-domain data, may end up structurally advantaged in the narrow sense of facing less litigation exposure, but disadvantaged in the broader sense of training on a thinner, more dated corpus than what incumbents can now buy exclusive rights to.
What resolution actually looks like
The most likely endpoint, on current evidence, is not a single decisive appellate ruling but a slow convergence toward the licensing-market outcome — because it lets labs keep training, lets rights holders get paid, and lets courts avoid writing a rule broad enough to either shut down an industry or void a century of copyright doctrine. Congress has shown little appetite to legislate a clean statutory license along the lines of music’s compulsory-license regime. The bills that have been introduced go to transparency rather than licensing — Representative Adam Schiff’s Generative AI Copyright Disclosure Act of April 2024, which expired with the 118th Congress, and the bipartisan TRAIN Act of July 2025, which would let rights holders subpoena training records and which sits in the Senate Judiciary Committee — and neither has come to a vote. Absent that, expect the terms to be set contract by contract, lab by lab, largely out of public view — which means the industry’s eventual data-rights regime will look less like a law and more like a set of private treaties, drafted by whoever had the leverage to demand one.
Sources
- Bartz v. Anthropic, Order on Fair Use (N.D. Cal., 23 June 2025)
- Authors Guild, What Authors Need to Know About the Anthropic Settlement; Textbook and Academic Authors Association on final approval (22 July 2026); JURIST (July 2026)
- Kadrey v. Meta, Order on Summary Judgment (N.D. Cal., 25 June 2025)
- Getty Images v. Stability AI [2025] EWHC 2863 (Ch), Courts and Tribunals Judiciary; Latham & Watkins summary
- Andersen v. Stability AI, Order on Motions to Dismiss (N.D. Cal., 12 August 2024)
- Music Business Worldwide on the Universal–Udio settlement (29 October 2025); TechCrunch on the Warner–Suno settlement (25 November 2025)
- Crowell & Moring on Reddit v. Anthropic remand (March 2026)
- US Copyright Office summary of Authors Guild v. Google (2d Cir. 2015)
- Licensing deals: PBS/AP (13 July 2023); TechCrunch on Axel Springer (13 December 2023); Bloomberg via Yahoo Finance on The Atlantic and Vox Media (29 May 2024); Nieman Lab on the News Corp deal (23 May 2024); Reuters via Yahoo on the Reddit–Google deal (22 February 2024)
- ProRata
- H.R. 7913, Generative AI Copyright Disclosure Act of 2024 (govinfo); S. 2455, TRAIN Act (govinfo)